More on Tobin Rote and the Lions

From Pro Football Weekly (June 29, 2000)

Tobin Rote, the quarterback who guided the Lions to their last NFL championship in 1957 while filling in for injured Hall of Famer Bobby Layne, has died. He was 72….

The Lions platooned Rote and Layne at quarterback before Rote finished off the ’57 season after Layne broke his leg in the regular season’s second-to-last game.

In the divisional playoff, the Lions trailed the 49ers 24-7 at halftime. Through the dressing room walls at San Francisco’s old Kezar Stadium, they could hear the 49ers already beginning their celebration.

“We could hear them laughing,” Rote said in ’91. “The walls were paper thin. They were going on about how they were going to spend their championship game money. It made us angry.”

In the second half, the Lions scored three touchdowns in four minutes, 29 seconds and went on to win 31-27.

The next Sunday at home in Briggs Stadium, the Lions won their third championship in six years with a 59-14 rout of the Browns. Rote threw four TD passes and ran for another.

Named as a counterpoint to the baseball Tigers

On this date in 1957, Tobin Rote threw for four touchdowns and ran for another as the Detroit Lions defeated the Cleveland Browns, 59-14, in the NFL championship game. It was the Lions’ third title of the Fifties, all over the Browns.

Since then the Lions have missed 37 out of 46 post seasons and are 1-9 in games when they did make it.

Michael Wilbon on Brett Favre

It’s a relief when anything good can come from so much physical and emotional pain. In the specific case of Brett Favre it was downright uplifting, to see a man so honor his father, who at one point had also been his coach, by not just playing 24 hours after his death, but by playing his best, by playing so magically he elevated his teammates and brought an opponent to its knees.

It was emotionally wrenching to watch Favre play Monday night, probably because it hit a little too close to home for some of us, losing a father at 58, losing the man who coached you before anybody else coached you, losing the first man you played catch with, the man whose approval you sought on the ball field or the court since you first grasped the notion of competition and how cool it was to share it with your dad.

Favre didn’t just bring honor to his own father, Irvin; he brought honor to all the kids and fathers who tossed the football or baseball in the backyard, particularly those who had to part before it was time. We already knew how physically tough Favre is. He’s Cal Ripken tough. He doesn’t miss a start, no matter what’s hurting. Nothing is revered in pro football like physical toughness and Favre has that in such abundance it’s scary. But what happened Monday night defines the NFL regular season that’s about to end, much the way baseball’s regular season was defined in large part by Barry Bonds hitting those late-summer, game-winning home runs after the death of his father and hero, Bobby Bonds.

The producers of all these silly reality shows think they can manufacture drama and emotion by locking some stiff in a box with snakes or forcing two teams of knuckleheads to spend a couple of weeks on a deserted island. They work every angle to create an outcome, to stage melodrama, and often draw millions of viewers in the process. Yet, their scripted junk can never, ever produce something as real, as unrehearsed and as compelling as Monday night in Oakland, when a 34-year-old man playing on adrenaline and memories threw for 399 yards.

This is what’s meant by the phrase, “the human drama of athletic competition.” Only sport gives you such reality. Only sport is so audacious as to ask, “Okay, Brett that was nice. So now, do it again.”

Read the whole column.

Decline of Western Civilization

From the Tuesday Morning Quarterback

Proof on the Decline of Western Civilization

At 11 p.m. ET during the Pats-at-Jets broadcast, ESPN offered viewers an online poll. Within minutes, 215,120 voted. This means at least 215,120 people were watching television and using their computers simultaneously — at 11 p.m. on a Saturday night.

More Proof on the Decline of Western Civilization

Television ads for the new Nissan Titan mega-pickup say at the bottom in tiny type, SIMULATED DEMONSTRATION. A “simulated” demonstration? “Demonstration: the act of showing or making evidence; conclusive evidence, proof.” (American Heritage Dictionary.) “Simulation: an imitation, a sham; the assumption of a false appearance.” (American Heritage Dictionary.) Something that is simulated cannot be a demonstration; simulations are, by nature, phony.

Mike Price back

From the Morning Briefing in the Los Angeles Times

Former Washington State coach Mike Price couldn’t have been sure about getting another football job after his firing seven months ago by Alabama because of a highly publicized visit to a Florida strip joint and allegations — a majority of which he has vehemently denied — about a night spent with strippers.

But not only does Price have a new coaching job, at Texas El Paso, he’s in a town apparently willing to give him the benefit of the doubt.

“Of course, that’s why he’s in El Paso and not going to Rose Bowls or rebuilding Alabama under the spiritual aura of Bear Bryant. Nobody else wanted him,” wrote El Paso Times columnist Joe Muench. “But UTEP needed him, and he’s willing to work for UTEP pay … and the Miners get a big-timer.”

Still, “Roll, Miners, roll!” doesn’t have the same ring to it.

Short story

Also from the Morning Briefing

There are already two books about LeBron James on the market, “King James: Believe the Hype” and “The Rise of a Star.”

Said TNT’s Steve Kerr: “What do you write about when you’re 18 — the kindergarten years were great…. What’s Chapter 4, seventh grade?”

Talkin’ trash

From the Morning Briefing in the Los Angeles Times

In a new NBA promo featuring “Sesame Street” characters, Big Bird says, “I love this game because of two words — Larry Bird.”

From Oscar the Grouch: “I love this game because of the trash talk.”

The Truth Hurts

If you enjoy reading about the Redskins’ failures, as NewMexiKen does, you’ll like Thomas Boswell’s column today.

Meanwhile, Tim Hasselbeck had a 0.0 quarterback rating, tying a record that can never be broken. It’s not like the SAT. You don’t get points for signing your name….

For those who want to make the case that Spurrier is many miles away from becoming an elite NFL coach, then this game can serve as their Exhibit A. The Redskins prepared for the same blitz-crazed defense that the Cowboys used to beat them, 21-14, in Dallas in November. “We prepared for them to come after us a lot. We felt we had a lot of answers for that,” Hasselbeck said. “But they played us differently than they did last time.”

What a shock. Parcells’s team switched tactics. The Redskins prepared, primarily, for the last war. Indeed, the Cowboys almost never blitzed. “They have Bill Parcells, so they are very well-prepared,” Coles said. “It seems that they are anticipating what you are going to do. When you run a route, it seems like they are waiting for you.”…

“People are going to talk about the coaches this week and whatever,” said a disgusted Smoot. “But between the Wilsons and the clocks, the game is about the players, not the coaches. . . . We didn’t play today. . . . Half the guys did, half the guys didn’t.

That’s good — “between the Wilsons and the clocks.” (Wilson is the brand of football the NFL uses.)

The Lunacy of the Heisman

Allen Barra has a solid piece on the Heisman. Published Friday, it’s still pertinent — and he predicted White would win.

The Mackey, the Lombardi, the Outland, the Biletnikoff—there are more than a dozen college football awards, and all of them taken together don’t generate one-tenth of the ink given to the Heisman Trophy. Why, exactly? What is particularly puzzling is that the Walter Camp Award, presented to the “nation’s top player” by the Walter Camp Foundation, has never caught on, considering that it is named for the father of football, the man without whom none of the other awards would exist. But then, the Walter Camp Foundation is in New Haven, Conn., and the Heisman Trophy is presented by the Downtown Athletic Club in New York. Which, come to think of it, probably answers the question right there….

And, by the way, why not present the Heisman sometime in mid-January, after the bowl games have been played? Why continue the pretense that the bowls aren’t part of the “season”? Since the bowl games determine the national championship and final rankings, why do the various groups and foundations that give out trophies pretend that the biggest games these kids will play don’t matter?

Every year, sportswriters wail and wail for a Heisman overhaul, and still nothing changes. So here’s a more feasible remedy. College football would gain some credibility by simply acknowledging that modern football is a division of labor among specialists. Gather up all the various year-end awards, including the Heisman, rent a ballroom, and present them all on the same night. If we can’t get the best players checked off on the Heisman ballot, maybe we can at least get them all in the same room.

I wanna be like Mike

From Morning Briefing in the Los Angeles Times:

Steven Vanderpool of Stats, Inc., said LeBron James already has had five games in which he didn’t score in double figures. “In comparison,” Vanderpool e-mailed, “in the 930 regular-season games he played with the Chicago Bulls, Michael Jordan failed to score in double figures only once — during the 1985-86 season shortly after returning from a broken foot.”

Tiger’s strength

From Morning Briefing in the Los Angeles Times:

Peter Kostis, working the Target World Challenge for the USA network, said, “If you want to find out where Tigers Woods has had his dinner on the PGA Tour — during his entire career he’s 16 under par on the par-threes, 89 under on the par-fours and 1,066 under part on the par-fives.”

The Big Dipper…

was Wilt Chamberlain’s preferred nickname (not Wilt-the-Stilt). The Morning Briefing in the Los Angeles Times has this —

Several readers e-mailed to say Chamberlain’s most amazing accomplishment may have been that he averaged 48.5 minutes a game in 1961-62. He averaged more than the maximum because the Philadelphia Warriors played a few overtime games that season.

He missed eight minutes all season — when he was ejected from a game against the Lakers after his third technical.

Chamberlain scored 50 or more points in a game 118 times during his NBA career.

Trivia questions: Chameberlain left college before his senior year at a time when it was unheard of and the NBA wouldn’t accept players until their class graduated. What did he do that year? What college did he leave?

Football playoffs

From Morning Briefing in the Los Angeles Times

There is a 16-team college football playoff after all. Except the games are video games. CSTV and EA Sports got together to create a fantasy playoff that involves the top 15 BCS-ranked teams and Boise State.

Results of the first-round games will be announced on CSTV today at 4:30 p.m., with quarterfinal results coming Dec. 17, and semifinals Dec. 27. The champion will be crowned in the Crystal Bowl Jan. 4.

It’s another possible title for USC, which opens up against Purdue.

There’s Only One Answer: Playoffs

Michael Wilbon argues for a playoff.

Let me declare my baggage right now: I hate the BCS. I hate figure skating for pretty much the same reason. Anything that focuses attention on something other than the actual competition is inadequate, and often winds up being unfair. The debate becomes the issue, not the contest. The process runs too big a risk of providing a final result that is unfulfilling, or in this case ridiculous.

One game short

Tony Kornheiser on the System Crash

The irony is that the BCS unwittingly got it right in one sense. It set up the perfect semifinals. LSU, at home in New Orleans, against Oklahoma in one game; USC, at home in California, against Michigan in the other. All that’s missing is the next game: The true national championship final.

Well, I guess

USC Coach Pete Carroll said Sunday, “It seems so crazy that I’m watching Hawaii against Boise State at midnight and it matters to us. I don’t have all the answers but I think it’s clear there are some issues.”

He Hopes They Won’t Be the Toast of the Town

From Morning Briefing in the Los Angeles Times

The Lakers are 16-3, have won eight in a row and talk of records has already started.

TNT’s Steve Kerr, a member of the 1995-96 Chicago Bulls team that set the NBA record by finishing the regular season 72-10, said he doesn’t think the Lakers can top that.

Taking a cue from the 1972 Miami Dolphins, Kerr said he’ll have a champagne toast once the Lakers lose their 11th game.

Raiders Are a Team Only Freud Could Love

From the Morning Briefing in the Los Angeles Times:

Dwight Perry of the Seattle Times found this question on a Raider IQ test, administered by ESPN.com’s Graham Hays: “How many yards does it take to make a first down?”

The multiple-choice answers were: (A) 5, (B) 10, (C) 15, (D) 20, (E) 30.

The correct answer, according to Hays: “E — after factoring in the 20 yards you’ve already been penalized for holding and intentional grounding.”

Good start

Los Angeles Times: “USC is in negotiations to open next season against Virginia Tech in the BCA Football Classic, a school athletic official said Thursday.” This year the Hokies opened with Central Florida and the Trojans with Auburn.

In the College Bowl Race, the Crucial Players Are the Programmers

Some background on the BCS computers from The New York Times.

This weekend will mark the end of the regular season in college football, and barring upsets of the top-ranked teams, there will be a tight race for the No. 2 spot in the nation.

So who would then help determine which team – Louisiana State or Southern California – would play top-ranked Oklahoma for the national championship, and which would be consigned to a lesser bowl game?

Why, an astrophysicist, of course; and an immunologist and an M.I.T.-trained mathematician from Indiana, not to mention a math professor from Virginia.

Granted, this is only part of the puzzle, but a crucial part nonetheless. Although games are won and lost on the field, the big-picture results come well after the last interception, fumble or field goal, when rankings derived from elaborate computer formulas are factored into the race known as the Bowl Championship Series.

C_Schilling1966 Has Entered the Room

Seth Stevenson on What happens when a Red Sox pitcher logs on?

Soon after, once a deal had been struck, Red Sox owner John Henry posted a message announcing as much, and thanking SOSH for the great impression it had made on Schilling. Then Schilling logged back on again and chatted some more—this time answering questions about the comparative hotness of the Olsen twins, and who’d win in a fight between a shark and a bear. (Schilling went with the bear.)….

The network effect of bringing these intelligent fans together, all of them striving to outwit and out-argue each other, all of them posting links to news items the second they hit the wire, creates an astonishing resource. A resource that just whups ass on the local hacks [sportswriters] and renders them nearly irrelevant.

The Internet is changing everything.